Coulomb’s and Franklin’s Laws Based Optimization for Nonconvex Economic and Emission Dispatch Problems

Murugesan Suman, Vadugapalayam Ponnuvel Sakthivel


The economic and emission dispatch (EED) problem addresses to minimize the fuel cost as well as the emission from the thermal power plants referring the equality and inequality constraints. Thus, the multi-objective EED problem optimizes the contradicting objectives concurrently. The non-smooth and non-convex fuel cost function such as valve point loading (VPL) effect acts as additional impediment for EED problem. These limitations drive the EED problem to be a highly nonlinear and a multimodal optimization problem. In this article, a new heuristic approach, Coulomb’s and Franklin’s laws based optimization (CFLBO) algorithm is bestowed to solve the nonconvex economic and emission dispatch problem. The proposed EED considers the non-smooth and nonconvex cost characteristics to ape the VPL effects. The CFLBO approach is concocted from the Coulomb’s and Franklin’s theories, and comprises attraction /repulsion, probabilistic ionization and contact stages. Applying these CFLBO stages has inflicted in upgrading the robustness and search proficiency of the approach, and substantially lessening the number of generations required to accomplish the optimal solution. The fuel cost and the environmental emission functions are viewed as objective functions and developed as a bi-objective EED problem. The bi-objective EED problem is tackled after converting EED problem to a solitary objective function optimization issue by weighted sum approach with price penalty factors. A fuzzy based concessive approach is employed to choose the best compromised solution from the non-dominated solution sets. To demonstrate its competence, the proposed CFLBO algorithm is employed to 10 and 40-units test systems with nonconvex characteristic. The simulation results signify that the CFLBO algorithm affords the best concessive solution and outruns the other compared state-of –the-art approaches.


combined economic and emission dispatch; economic/emission dispatch; heuristic approach; multi-objective optimization; non-dominated solution

Full Text:



Abido M.A., 2009. Multiobjective particle swarm optimization for environmental/economic dispatch problem. Electric Power Systems Research 79 (7): 1105–1113.

Zhan J.P., Wu Q.H., Guo C.X., Zhou X.X., 2014. Fast lambda-iteration method for economic dispatch. IEEE Transactions on Power Systems 29(2): 990–991.

Chen S.-D. and J.-F. Chen. 2003. A direct Newton–raphson economic emission dispatch. International Journal of Electrical Power and Energy Systems 25(5): 411–417.

Bishe H.M., Kian A.R., Esfahani M.S., 2011. A Primal-dual Interior point method for solving environmental/economic power dispatch problem. International Review of Electrical Engineering 6(3): 1463–1473.

Ji-Yuan F. and Z. Lan. 1998. Real-time economic dispatch with line flow and emission constraints using quadratic programming. IEEE Transactions on Power System 13(2): 320–325.

Koridak L.A. and M. Rahli. 2010. Optimization of the emission and economic dispatch by the genetic algorithm. Prz Elektrotech 86: 363–366.

Basu M., 2005. A simulated annealing-based goal-attainment method for economic emission load dispatch of fixed head hydrothermal power systems. International Journal of Electric Power and Energy System 27: 147–53.

Abou A.A., Ela E.L., Abido M.A., Spea S.R., 2010. Differential evolution algorithm for emission constrained economic power dispatch problem. Electric Power Systems Research 80(10): 1286–92.

Ratniyomchai T., Oonsivilai A., Pao-La-Or P., and Kulworawanichpong T., 2010. Particle swarm optimization for solving combined economic and emission dispatch problems. Athens: World Scientific and Engineering Acad and Soc.

Karakonstantis I. and A. Vlachos. 2015. Ant colony optimization for continuous domains applied to emission and economic dispatch problems. Journal of Information and Optimization Sciences 36(1-2): 23–42.

Hota P.k., Barisal A.K., and Chakrabarti R., 2010. Economic emission load dispatch through fuzzy based bacterial foraging algorithm. International Journal of Electrical Power and Energy System 32(7): 794–803.

Sivasubramani S. and K. Swarup. 2011. Environmental/economic dispatch using multiobjective harmony search algorithm. Electrical Power System Research 81(9): 1778–85.

Aydin D., Ozyon S., Yasar C., and Liao T.J., 2014. Artificial bee colony algorithm with dynamic population size to combined economic and emission dispatch problem. International Journal of Electrical Power and Energy Systems 54: 144–153.

Secui D.C., 2015. A new modified artificial bee colony algorithm for the economic dispatch problem. Energy Conversion and Management 89: 43–62.

Chandrasekaran K. and S.P. Simon. 2012. Firefly algorithm for reliable/emission/economic dispatch multi objective problem. International Review of Electrical Engineering 7(1): 3414–25.

Bhattacharya A. and P.K. Chattopadhyay. 2010. application of biogeography-based optimization for solving multi-objective economic emission load dispatch problems. Electric Power Components Systems 38(3): 340–365.

Chandrasekaran K., Simon S.P., and Padhy N.P., 2014. Cuckoo search algorithm for emission reliable economic multi-objective dispatch problem. IETE Journal of Research 60(2): 128–138.

Güvenç U., Sönmez Y., Duman S., Yörükeren N., 2012. Combined economic and emission dispatch solution using gravitational search algorithm. Scientia Iranica 19(6): 1754–62.

Ramesh B., Chandra Jagan Mohan V., Veera Reddy V.C., 2013. Application of bat algorithm for combined economic load and emission dispatch. Journal of Electrical Engineering (13): 214–9.

Abdelaziz A.Y., Ali E.S., Abd Elazim S.M., 2016. Flower pollination algorithm to solve combined economic and emission dispatch problems. International Journal of Engineering Science and Technology 19(2): 980–990.

Bhattacharjee K., Bhattacharya A., Halder nee Dey S., 2015. Backtracking search optimization based economic environmental power dispatch problems. International Journal of Electrical Power and Energy System 73: 830–842.

Mostafa Kheshti., Xiaoning Kang., Jiangtao Li., Pawel Regulski., Vladimir Terzija., 2018.Lightning flash algorithm for solving nonconvex combined emission economic dispatch with generator constraints. IET Generation, Transmission and Distribution 12(1): 104-116.

Bhattacharjee K., Bhattacharya A., Halder nee Dey S., 2014. Solution of economic emission load dispatch problems of power systems by real coded chemical reaction algorithm. Electrical Power and Energy Systems 59: 176–187.

Robert T.F., King A.H., Harry C.S., Rughooputh K., Deb K., 2004. Evolutionary multiobjective environmental /economic dispatch: stochastic versus deterministic approaches. KanGAL, Rep. 2004019: 1–15.

Abido M.A., 2006. Multiobjective evolutionary algorithms for power dispatch problem. IEEE Trans. Evol. Comput 10(3): 315–329.

Basu M., 2011. Economic environmental dispatch using multi-objective differential evolution. International Journal of Appl Soft Comput 11(2): 2845–2853.

Roy P.K. and S. Bhui. 2013. Multi-objective quasi-oppositional teaching learning based optimization for economic emission load dispatch problem. International Journal of Electrical Power and Energy Systems 53: 937–948.

Zhang R., Zhou J., Mo L., and Ouyang S., 2013. Economic environmental dispatch using an enhanced multi-objective cultural algorithm. Electrical Power System Research 99: 18–29.

Manteaw E.D. and N.A. Odero. 2012. Combined economic and emission dispatch solution using ABC_PSO hybrid algorithm with valve point loading effect, International Journal of Scientific and Research Publication 2(12): 1–9.

Edwin Selva Rex C.R., Marsaline Beno M., and Annrose J., 2019. A solution for combined economic and mission dispatch problem using hybrid optimization techniques. Journal of Electrical Engineering and Technology.

Maity D., Banerjee S., and Chanda C.K., 2019. Bare bones teaching learning-based optimization technique for economic emission load dispatch problem considering transmission losses. Iranian Journal of Science and Technology, Transactions of Electrical Engineering 43: 77–90.

Bhargava G. and N.K. Yadav. 2020. Solving combined economic emission dispatch model via hybrid differential evaluation and crow search algorithm. Evolutionary Intelligence.

Ghasemi M., Ghavidel S., Aghaei J., Akbari E., and Li L., 2018. CFA optimizer: A new and powerful algorithm inspired by Franklin’s and Coulomb’s laws theory for solving the economic load dispatch problems. Int. Trans. Electr. Energy Syst. 28:e2536.